Rubber Soul Super Deluxe: The Beatles’ 5LP Box Set Review

I’ve been waiting for this one since the Revolver Super Deluxe came out back in 2022, and honestly, the Rubber Soul Super Deluxe box set is the reissue Beatles collectors have been asking for the longest. Giles Martin and Sam Okell went back to the original four-track masters, Peter Jackson’s WingNut team ran their de-mixing technology on the tapes, and the whole thing lands on October 2, 2026 as a 5LP box, a 4CD set, or a handful of smaller configurations.

My take, right up front: if you already own a couple of these Super Deluxe Beatles reissues, you know exactly what you’re getting into, and it’s worth it mainly if the unreleased material and the mono-versus-stereo comparison genuinely matter to you. Whether you’re into vinyl reissues, gaming collector’s editions like the Halo Campaign Evolved Collector’s Edition, or film sets like the 007 First Light Collector’s Edition, the value question is always the same one: does the packaging and bonus content actually justify the premium over the standard version?

Quick take: the Rubber Soul Super Deluxe 5LP box gets you three full versions of the album (new stereo mix, original mono, and the Capitol US edition), 26 tracks of sessions and demos including a never-before-heard John Lennon sketch called “Little Girl,” and an 88-page hardbound book, all for $229.98. It’s a lot of the same fourteen songs dressed differently, so this really comes down to how deep your Beatles shelf already runs.

• What is the Rubber Soul Super Deluxe edition?
• Everything included in the 5LP Super Deluxe box
• Price and availability: is it worth $229.98?
• Our Take
• FAQs

Format	5LP + 7″ single (also sold as a 4CD set, a standalone Blu-ray, 2LP/2CD Deluxe editions, and 1LP/1CD Standard editions)
Total tracks	68 tracks across the five LPs and the single
Vinyl specs	180-gram, half-speed mastered
Mixes included	New stereo mix, original mono master, original Capitol US mix (the Dolby Atmos mix is Blu-ray only)
Book	88-page hardbound book with a new Paul McCartney introduction and a foreword drawn from John Lennon’s own words
Packaging	12″ x 12″ slipcase
Release date	October 2, 2026
Label	Apple Corps Ltd. / Capitol / UMe

What I like:

• Genuinely new material: 20 previously unreleased takes, three unreleased home demos, and the John Lennon song sketch “Little Girl,” which nobody even knew existed before this announcement
• Mono, stereo, and the Capitol US mix sitting in the same box, so you can actually A/B them instead of hunting down three separate pressings
• Half-speed mastering pulled straight from the four-track masters, with the same de-mixing approach that made the Revolver reissue sound so clean
• The 88-page book reads like an actual reference piece, not a glorified insert

What holds it back:

• The Dolby Atmos mix isn’t in the vinyl or CD Super Deluxe box at all, you need the separate $35.98 Blu-ray for that
• $229.98 is a lot to pay for three versions of the same fourteen songs plus outtakes
• No mono mix for “Day Tripper” or “We Can Work It Out,” which feels like an odd omission for completists
• Early tracklists floating around before release didn’t list “Run For Your Life” on the mono LP, so it’s worth double-checking your copy against the final pressing

What is the Rubber Soul Super Deluxe edition?

At its core, this is a ground-up revisit of Rubber Soul, the 1965 album that Apple Corps and UMG are treating with the same care they gave Revolver four years earlier. The headline is the new stereo mix, built from the original four-track masters using de-mixing technology developed by Emile de la Rey’s team at Peter Jackson’s WingNut Films, the same audio restoration work that powered the Get Back documentary. That’s not marketing fluff, either, it’s the reason Giles Martin can push John’s vocal on “In My Life” forward without smearing the strings behind it.

What makes this particular reissue interesting to me, and something I haven’t seen explained clearly elsewhere, is that Rubber Soul was recorded in just four weeks right after Shea Stadium, and it shows in how differently the sessions material sounds compared to Revolver’s outtakes. You can hear the band figuring things out in real time across the 26 tracks of sessions and demos, from early takes of “Norwegian Wood” to a guitar rehearsal for “Michelle.” It’s messier and more human than the polished outtakes on some of the later box sets, and for me that’s the whole appeal.

The new stereo mix and why the half-speed mastering matters

Half-speed mastering isn’t a new trick, but it matters more here than on a lot of reissues because the original 1965 stereo mix was famously rough, with vocals hard-panned to one channel and instruments dumped into the other. The 2026 mix fixes that without pretending the album was recorded in 2026, which is a tightrope Giles Martin has walked with mixed success on other Beatles catalog releases. On my system, the difference on “Nowhere Man” and “In My Life” is obvious within the first fifteen seconds.

Reddit’s r/beatles community has been picking apart the mix since the announcement, and one detailed listener comparison posted there described the new mix as pushing vocals “waaaay up” while pulling the band “waaaay back,” which lines up with what I’m hearing too. If you loved the 2022 Revolver remix, you’ll likely feel the same way here. If you prefer the rawer original balance, this isn’t going to convert you, and that’s a fair thing to know before you spend $229.98.

Everything included in the 5LP Super Deluxe box

The physical contents of the Rubber Soul Super Deluxe box break down cleanly once you separate the “album” discs from the “extras” discs. LP1 carries the new stereo mix, LP4 is the original mono master, and LP5 is the 12-track Capitol US edition, meaning you get three legitimately different listening experiences of the same record without buying three separate box sets. LP2 and LP3 hold the 26-track sessions and demos collection, and the 7″ single covers “Day Tripper” and “We Can Work It Out” in stereo.

Packaging-wise, everything sits inside a 12″ x 12″ slipcase with individual poly-lined sleeves for each LP, similar in spirit to how I felt unboxing the Star Wars Skywalker Saga box set, where the slipcase earns its keep through genuine content rather than empty bulk. The 88-page hardbound book is the real centerpiece for me, with a new McCartney introduction, a Lennon foreword assembled from his own past comments, rare photos, and proper track-by-track notes rather than recycled liner notes.

The book, the single, and small details that add up

The “Little Girl” inclusion deserves its own mention because it’s not a remix or an alternate take of something you already know, it’s a previously unheard, unrumored John Lennon composition that came from the Lennon estate during production. Giles Martin has said it plays like a rough sketch, unfinished lyrically, but it’s the kind of find that justifies the “Super Deluxe” label better than another instrumental backing track would have.

On the other hand, a few small choices are already dividing the fanbase. Neither “Day Tripper” nor “We Can Work It Out” gets a mono mix in this set, and the demo for “What Goes On” that some collectors expected didn’t make the cut. None of that ruins the box, but if you’re the type who notices these things (and if you’re reading a Rubber Soul review in this much detail, you probably are), it’s worth setting expectations before you pre-order.

Price and availability: is it worth $229.98?

At $229.98 for the 5LP box, the Rubber Soul Super Deluxe sits right in line with recent Beatles Super Deluxe pricing, and it’s drawn the same reaction the last few reissues did. On r/beatles, one commenter summed up the general mood pretty bluntly, calling it “crazy” for what amounts to three versions of one album, a sentiment echoed across that entire discussion thread. If $229.98 still feels steep, it helps to compare it against something like the Marvel Infinity Saga collector’s box, where the premium comes from sheer scale rather than three takes on the same fourteen songs.

The four-disc CD version runs less per format but still isn’t cheap once you add the standalone Blu-ray for the Dolby Atmos mix, which several fans on Reddit pointed out feels like it should have been bundled in. If your budget tops out around $25 to $40, the 2LP or 2CD Deluxe editions cover the new stereo mix plus a curated set of highlights without the full sessions disc or the 88-page book, and that’s genuinely the smarter buy for casual listeners rather than the Super Deluxe.

Vinyl versus CD versus the standalone Blu-ray

If you’re mainly chasing audio quality over physical bulk, the Blu-ray is oddly the best value in the whole lineup at $35.98, since it’s the only format carrying the Dolby Atmos mix and hi-res 96kHz/24-bit stereo. The catch is that it skips every outtake and demo entirely, so it works best as a companion purchase rather than a replacement for the CD or vinyl box.

Compared to the 2022 Revolver Super Deluxe, the format structure here feels familiar: the same half-speed mastering pitch, the same three-mixes-in-one-box logic, and the same slipcase style. The real upgrade over Revolver is that Atmos exists at all in physical form this time, since Revolver never got a surround disc, something Beatles collectors on Reddit have brought up repeatedly as an oversight worth correcting.

Our Take

Setting the outtakes and mixes aside for a second, what actually sold me on this box is “Little Girl.” A previously unknown Lennon song showing up in 2026, fully sourced and cleared by the estate, is the kind of thing that doesn’t happen very often anymore in Beatles reissues, and it alone makes the Rubber Soul Super Deluxe tier worth considering over the 2LP Deluxe.

This is a box for the collector who already owns the mono box set and the 2022 Revolver reissue and wants the same treatment applied to Rubber Soul, not for someone who just wants to hear the album for the first time. Casual fans should absolutely start with the standard 1LP or the orange vinyl pressing instead. If you enjoyed how we broke down the Harry Potter Illustrated Collection, the logic here is nearly identical: you’re paying for the book and the presentation almost as much as the music itself. It’s available for pre-order now ahead of the October 2 street date, on vinyl, CD, and the standalone Blu-ray. I’d love to hear in the comments which format you’re going with, and honestly, what you wish they’d included that didn’t make the final tracklist.

Disclosure: this page may contain affiliate links; Five Star Edition may earn a commission on qualifying purchases.